Navigating the Cosmos: Need for Comprehensive Space Law in India

February 28, 2024
Indian Space Association (ISpA)

By Rupin Chopra and Shantam Sharma

The Indian space sector, valued at $9.6 billion[1] in 2020, is poised to contribute 2%-3% of the global space economy, with an ambitious target of 10% by 2030. As India achieves significant milestones, including the successful launches of Chandrayaan 3 and Aditya L1 (solar observatory)[2], and plans for future manned space missions, the absence of a robust legal framework becomes increasingly apparent. Unlike countries such as Canada, Germany, the Netherlands, South Africa, and Ukraine, India lacks comprehensive space laws, hindering its ability to regulate the burgeoning commercial space sector.

Current Regulatory Landscape

India’s space activities are currently regulated by the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), established in 1969 and the National Remote Sensing Centre (NRSC) Guidelines of 2011[3]. However, these legislations fall short in addressing the complex issues arising from the expansion of the space sector, including authorization, contracts, dispute resolution, licensing, data processing and distribution, certification of space technology, insurance, and legal complexities related to launch services.

In the global arena, space law plays a pivotal role in safeguarding national interests and assets. The Outer Space Treaty, established by the United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs (UNOOSA), forms the foundation of international space law. Notably, countries like the United States and the United Kingdom have well-defined space laws that govern activities through acts like the National Aeronautics and Space Act (1958) and the Outer Space Act (1986), respectively.

Challenges and Opportunities

The absence of comprehensive space laws poses challenges for India’s space sector, particularly in facilitating private sector participation, safeguarding national interests, and fostering innovation. However, these challenges also present opportunities for the government to craft forward-looking legislation that addresses the complexities of modern space activities. The emergence of IN-SPACe[4] in 2020 marked a shift towards commercialization. Despite this, gaps persist in the following regions:

  • Tax Incentives and Legislative Framework:Challenge: The absence of tax incentives diminishes the appeal of the space sector for private players.
    Opportunity: The introduction of tax incentives and a supportive legislative framework could serve as catalysts, encouraging private investments and driving growth within the space industry.
  • Space Policy Inconsistencies:Challenge: The 2023 space policy has raised concerns about inconsistencies, potentially introducing uncertainties for stakeholders.
    Opportunity: A comprehensive space law has the potential to address these inconsistencies, providing a stable and reliable legal environment for both public and private entities engaged in space activities.
  • Dispute Resolution Mechanisms:Challenge: Ambiguities in dispute resolution mechanisms for space-related activities can lead to uncertainties and potential conflicts.
    Opportunity: The incorporation of robust dispute resolution mechanisms in the space law can ensure timely and equitable resolution of conflicts, promoting an environment conducive to investment.
  • Licensing and Authorization Procedures:Challenge: Ambiguities in licensing procedures can impede the timely authorization of space activities, affecting project timelines.
    Opportunity: Clearly defined licensing procedures within the space law can streamline the authorization process, reducing bureaucratic hurdles for both government and private entities.
  • Data Processing and Distribution:Challenge: Lack of clarity on data processing and distribution regulations can pose challenges for entities involved in earth observation services.
    Opportunity: A comprehensive space law can establish detailed guidelines for data processing, ensuring proper utilization and distribution while addressing privacy and security concerns.
  • Limited Legislation for Growing Space Sector:Challenge: The absence of a dedicated space law hampers the effective regulation of a rapidly expanding space sector.
    Opportunity: The enactment of a comprehensive space law can lay a strong foundation, governing various aspects of space activities and creating an environment conducive to growth.
  • Ensuring Private Sector Confidence:Challenge: Private entities may hesitate to invest without clear legal frameworks safeguarding their interests.
    Opportunity: A well-defined space law can instill confidence in private players by offering legal protections, delineating liabilities, and providing a framework for fair business practices.
  • Space Sustainability and Debris Mitigation:Challenge: The increasing amount of space debris poses a threat to ongoing and future space missions.
    Opportunity: A comprehensive space law can incorporate provisions for space debris mitigation, ensuring responsible space activities and adherence to international standards.
  • Encouraging Innovation and Research:Challenge: Without supportive legal frameworks, innovation in space-related technologies may face obstacles.
    Opportunity: The space law can encourage innovation by providing a clear regulatory path for the development and deployment of new technologies, fostering research and development in the space sector.
  • Global Collaboration and Compliance:Challenge: The absence of a dedicated space law may hinder India’s collaboration with other nations and compliance with international space law standards.
    Opportunity: A robust space law can facilitate global collaboration by aligning India’s legal framework with international standards, enhancing the nation’s standing in the global space community.

Conclusion: Urgent Need for Space Laws in India

The creation of IN-SPACe in 2020 marked a pivotal moment, spurring debates around the privatization of India’s space program. While the government introduced the Space-based Communication Policy of India-2020 (Spacecom Policy-2020), the lack of comprehensive space laws remains a concern. The policy aims to regulate commercial satellite use and ground stations, signaling a shift toward a more commercialized space sector.

In conclusion, India’s growing prowess in space exploration and commercial activities demands a legal framework that aligns with international standards. The absence of comprehensive space laws poses challenges to private sector participation and leaves crucial aspects unregulated. As the global space race intensifies, India must expedite the formulation and enactment of robust space laws to safeguard its interests, foster innovation, and encourage private investment. The government’s initiatives, including the introduction of IN-SPACe and the Spacecom Policy-2020, are steps in the right direction, but a holistic legal framework is essential for India to truly unlock the potential of its burgeoning space sector. With a sector valued at $9.6 billion in 2020 and aiming for 10% of the global space economy by 2030, the time is ripe for India to establish comprehensive space laws to navigate the cosmos effectively and become a global leader in space exploration and commerce.

[1] Available at: https://www.investindia.gov.in/sector/space

[2] Available at: https://www.isro.gov.in/Aditya_L1.html

[3] Available at: https://www.nrsc.gov.in/EOP_irsdata_Policy/page_1?language_content_entity=en

[4] Available at: https://www.inspace.gov.in/inspace

Related Posts

Ongoing Benefits of Space Exploration: How Commercial Expansion Continues to Serve Humanity

PM Modi launches Indian Space Association (ISpA)

For more information please contact us at : info@ssrana.com