By Lucy Rana and Huda Jafri
The existence of prior art does not, by itself, establish that an invention lacks an inventive step. What matters is whether the cited prior art, considered in the context of the claimed invention and the knowledge of a person skilled in the art, renders the invention obvious. This distinction between identifying prior art and establishing obviousness was central to the Madras High Court’s decision in Kobelco Compressors Corporation v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs.
In this decision, Hon’ble Justice P.B. Balaji set aside the refusal of a patent application concerning a “SOUND INSULATING PACKAGE”, holding that merely referring to prior art documents and the features of the claimed invention was insufficient to justify rejection. Directing fresh examination by a different Patent Controller, the Court reaffirmed the importance of reasoned decision-making in patent examination and the need for a meaningful assessment of the claimed invention against the applicable statutory requirements.[1]
The Refusal and the Appeal
Kobelco Compressors Corporation, a Japanese company based in Tokyo and the appellant before the High Court, challenged the refusal of Indian Patent Application No. 202147013337. On 27 February 2024, the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs at the Patent Office in Chennai refused the application on two grounds: lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja) of the Patents Act, 1970, and failure to present the claims in a two-part format. Kobelco appealed to the High Court under Section 117-A of the Act.
Kobelco, argued that the Controller had not followed the principles laid down by the High Court of Delhi in F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. v. Cipla Ltd., that the courts have treated those steps as mandatory, and that the procedure adopted was therefore irregular. He sought remand so that the applicant could have a fair opportunity to put forth its claimed invention. He also asked for examination by a different Controller, since the officer who passed the order might have some prejudice and might not be open to reversing his earlier decision.
The Patent Office, submitted that the order had no infirmity. Relying on the counter filed in the appeal, he argued that Kobelco had shown no technical advancement over prior arts D1, D3 and D7, that the invention was already well known in view of its priority date, and that the claimed features were obvious. He relied on Lallubhai Chakubhai v. Chimanlal and Co. and on the Delhi High Court’s decision in Gogoro Inc. v. Controller of Patents and Designs to contend that the refusal was supported by reasoning.
What the Court Held
Hon’ble Justice P.B. Balaji heard both counsel, examined the records, and reserved judgment on 26 October 2026. He agreed with the appellant at the threshold. The Court found no discussion whatsoever behind the rejection, and reasons were also lacking. Mere reference to the prior arts and to the claimed invention would not suffice. The Controller, the Court said, must test the invention against the statutory requirements elaborately laid down by the Delhi High Court in Hoffmann.
The Court drew on its own earlier decisions. Justice Balaji recalled his judgment of 5 July 2024 in Cornell Research Foundation Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, where a patentee was held entitled to remand because no reasons were assigned and the response to the hearing notice was not discussed. He also referred to Pinnacle Engines Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, where an order that merely set out the elements of the claimed invention, without discussing it, was held unsustainable as effectively unreasoned.[2]
The appeal was allowed and the application remitted for fresh consideration. A fresh Patent Controller must decide it afresh after giving the appellant an opportunity to explain its claimed invention, and pass final orders within four months of receiving a copy of the judgment. No costs were awarded. The Court did not determine whether the invention is patentable, and did not separately adjudicate the objection on the two part claim format.
Directing a different officer is not unique to this case. In July 2026, the High Court of Madras ordered reconsideration by another officer, to preclude any possibility of pre-determination, in Elanco US Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, an appeal by a US applicant. The refusal order there had itself recorded that the invention differed from the closest prior art, yet rejected the application without explaining why.[3]
Why the Hoffmann Steps Matter
Section 2(1)(ja) defines an inventive step as a feature of an invention involving technical advance over existing knowledge or having economic significance, or both, and making the invention non-obvious to a person skilled in the art. In Cipla Ltd. v. F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd., decided on 27 November 2015, a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court articulated a five-step judicial inquiry for determining obviousness. The decision arose from patent litigation concerning erlotinib hydrochloride, a molecule associated with the treatment of non-small-cell lung cancer.[4]
The steps run as follows. First, identify the ordinary person skilled in the art. Second, identify the inventive concept. Third, attribute to that person the common general knowledge at the priority date. Fourth, identify the differences between the cited matter and the invention, and ask whether they are an ordinary application or require several theoretical and practical steps. Fifth, decide whether those differences, viewed with knowledge of the invention, would have been obvious, while ruling out hindsight.
The Delhi High Court continues to treat this test as the prevailing benchmark. In December 2025, it remanded a German applicant’s refused application because the order had not followed it. The Court directed a fresh hearing notice and gave the applicant liberty to file fresh written submissions.[5]
Conclusion
The Kobelco judgment does not say whether the invention deserves a patent. It says how that question must be answered: with an identified skilled person, an identified inventive concept, and reasons that a court can follow. The remand is a reset, not a grant. Until the fresh Controller decides, within four months, the application stands where it began, but now on a record that must be examined properly, and the objection on the two part claim format has yet to be adjudicated. For applicants in India, the message from Chennai is that a reasoned refusal can be defended, and an unreasoned one can be undone.
Aysha Sasmin, Intern at S.S.Rana & Co. has assisted in the research of this article.
[1]Kobelco Compressors Corporation v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, CMA (PT) No. 26 of 2024, High Court of Madras, 30 October 2026, 2026:MHC:4393.
[2]Cornell Research Foundation Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, (T) CMA (PT) No. 187 of 2023, 5 July 2024; Pinnacle Engines Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, 2024 SCC OnLine Mad 1052.
[3]Elanco US Inc. v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs, CMA (PT) No. 37 of 2024, High Court of Madras, 14 July 2026.
[4]F. Hoffmann-La Roche Ltd. v. Cipla Ltd., 2016 (65) PTC 1 (Del).
[5]Emitec Gesellschaft Fur Emissions Technologie MBH v. Controller General of Patents, Designs & Trademarks, C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 465/2022, High Court of Delhi, 24 December 2025.