By Lucy Rana and Bijit Das
Recently, Parle Products Pvt. Ltd. filed a civil suit against Future Group Ltd. alleging identical packaging infringement of Plaintiffs copyright combined with a cause of action for passing off, wherein it was found that the latterâs products had identical/deceptively similar in packaging to that of Parleâs products.
In the present case, Bombay High Court restrained, Future Consumer Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as âthe Defendantâ) from infringing Parleâs trademark in terms of the packaging of its products vide passing an ad-interim injunction order.
The Court held that âThere is no doubt that the rival labels are being used for identical products under nearly identical packaging and trade dresses. The similarity in the rival packaging/labels cannot be a matter of coincidence.â
Brief Facts
- Parle Products Pvt. Ltd. (herein referred to as the âPlaintiffâ) is the most chosen Fast-Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) brand since 2010. Plaintiff manufactures and sells a range of biscuits however not limited to confectioneries, cakes, wafers, etc.
- In the years 1939, 1971, and 1996 the Plaintiff began manufacturing its popular biscuits â âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ and âHIDE&SEEKâ respectively.
- Ever since, To secure its statutory rights in the âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ and âHIDE & SEEKâ trademark the Plaintiff had applied for and secured trademark registration in respect of the same under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
- In the months of July 2013, July 2014, and May 2017, the Plaintiff redesigned and created latest packaging for âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ and âHIDE&SEEKâ, respectively.
- Further, it was disclosed that the Plaintiffâs packaging was created/authored by Mr. Mayank Shah an employee of Plaintiff during his course of employment. Therefore, Plaintiff is the owner of the copyright in the packaging.
- In and around the second week of September 2020, Plaintiff came across the Defendants, biscuits bearing the mark âCRACKOâ, âKRACKER KINGâ and âPEEK-A-BOOâ having trade dresses/packaging/labels which were identical with and/or deceptively similar to and/or substantial reproduction of Plaintiffâs Packaging.
Issues Involved
After having found Defendantâs impugned products, Plaintiff produced photographs of Defendantâs impugned products âCRACKOâ, âKRACKER KINGâ, & âPEEK-A-BOOâ which were identical/deceptively similar to Plaintiffâs products âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ, and âHIDE AND SEEKâ with a cash memo of sale of the impugned products in Big Bazaar outlet in Ville Parle, Mumbai.
The aforementioned findings resulted in the formation of the following issues before the Bombay High Court:
- Whether the Plaintiffs are the owners of Copyright in Plaintiffâs packaging of their products âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ and âHIDE & SEEKâ?
- Whether the Defendants have blatantly copied the Plaintiffâs packaging and label concerning their aforementioned products?
Plaintiffâs Contentions
- It was submitted that according to the Nielsen Report for the year 2010 Plaintiffâs brand PARLE-G was certified as the worldâs largest selling biscuit brand.
- It is stated that since the beginning, Plaintiff has been openly, continuously, and extensively using Plaintiffsâ Packaging, upon and in respect of their goods in India.
- It is also stated that Plaintiff has taken efforts to popularize their products bearing its Packaging and have been expending substantial sums of money and efforts towards popularizing and promoting sales of the relevant goods in India.
- It was submitted that its Packaging includes the features thereof that have become distinctive of its goods and connote and denote to the members of the general public and trade the goods of Plaintiff alone and no one else.
- It was argued that the Defendants have intentionally stocked their impugned products on the shelves alongside Plaintiffsâ products
- It was contended that the Defendants had copied every element of Plaintiffsâ Packaging including the layout, color combination, placement, and all distinctive elements and features of Plaintiffsâ Packaging to the last millimeter.
- He further submitted that Defendantâs usage of Plaintiffâs trade dresses, labels, and packaging amounted to an infringement of Plaintiffâs copyrights and passing off.
Comparison between the two goods are reproduced below:


Identical Packaging Infringement- Similarity in rival packaging cannot be coincidence
- It was noted by the Honâble Bombay High Court (hereinafter referred to as âthe Courtâ) that a comparison of the rival products hardly leaves any doubt about how Defendants have blatantly copied Plaintiffsâ Packaging/labels. There is no doubt that the rival labels are being used for identical products under nearly identical packaging and trade dresses. The labels/artworks/packaging/trade dresses of Defendantsâ âCrackOâ, âKracker Kingâ and âPeek-a-Booâ products are a reproduction of Plaintiffsâ Packaging used in respect of their âMONACOâ, âKRACKJACKâ and âHIDE & SEEKâ products and/or reproductions of substantial parts thereof. Defendants must have had Plaintiffsâ products before them while designing the impugned packaging. The similarity in the rival packaging/labels cannot be a matter of coincidence.
- The Court held that there were prima facie evidences that the Plaintiffs were the original owners of copyrights on the packaging of their products through which their brand Parle has gained substantial value in terms of reputation and goodwill.
- With regards to the findings, Bombay High Court passed an ad-interim injunction order restraining the Defendants from reproducing, manufacturing, selling its products which are identical or deceptively similar to that of Plaintiffâs productsâ packaging, labelling, trade dress, layout or color scheme to pass off their impugned products as the Plaintiffâs products.
Related Posts
India: Developing Jurisprudence on Trade Dress
DELHI HIGH COURT DECLARES âKINDERâ A WELL-KNOWN TRADEMARK
