No Mosaicing, No Hindsight: Madras High Court Sees the Invention the Patent Office Missed, Orders Grant of The North Face’s Patent

November 18, 2026
No Mosaicing, No Hindsight

By Vikrant Rana and Huda Jafri

Can an examiner combine pieces of different prior-art documents, assemble them into an alleged invention and then declare that the invention lacks novelty or inventive step? The Madras High Court has delivered an important reminder that patent examination cannot work backwards from the claimed invention to manufacture obviousness.

In a significant judgment dated 16 October 2026, the Madras High Court allowed an appeal filed by The North Face Apparel Corp. and directed the Controller of Patents and Designs to grant its patent application. Hon’ble Justice K. Kumaresh Babu found that the Patent Office had dissected the claimed invention into isolated features and compared them with different prior-art documents, overlooking the technical contribution of the invention as a whole.

The judgment is particularly noteworthy because the Court did not merely remit the matter for fresh consideration. It set aside the refusal and expressly directed the grant of the patent.

The Invention and the Refusal

The North Face filed Indian Patent Application No. 202147026139 for an invention titled “Systems and Methods for End-to-End Article Management”. According to its counsel, the invention is an integrated process for managing and tracing articles such as clothing, apparel, accessories and fabric based components. It seeks to detect and minimise discrepancies so that articles are produced within the tight tolerance of the intended design, through continuous monitoring and correction.

The First Examination Report raised objections including lack of inventive step and non-patentability. The applicant replied on 31 May 2022 with amended claims and attended three hearings, filing written submissions and further amended claims after the first two. On 16 April 2025, the Controller refused the application, citing prior art documents D21 to D24. The North Face appealed under Section 117A of the Patents Act, 1970.

The Central Dispute

Counsel for The North Face argued that the Controller had broken the claimed invention into isolated features and matched them against separate documents. He relied on the spectrophotometer, which is the primary sensor in the invention, and on the invisible markers it detects, and said none of the cited documents used either. He added that a bidirectional data flow architecture enabling dynamic process rectification was absent from D23, and that the order had recorded findings in the appellant’s favour before rejecting the invention.

Senior Central Government Counsel for the Patent Office defended the refusal, and submitted that D21 and D23 disclose automated garment manufacturing and centralised control, D22 discloses identifier based tracking at multiple manufacturing stages, and D24 discloses carrying process information into later production. Together, they gave a person skilled in the art the motivation to reach the claimed subject matter.

The word mosaicing came from the Patent Office side, but in the opposite direction. Its counsel contended that the applicant had mosaiced unrelated prior arts and glued them together to claim an invention, and that the examiner had considered the invention as a whole.

Why the Court Rejected the Refusal

The Court examined the refusal order and the Patent Office’s counter affidavit. Although the Patent Office said the invention had been assessed as a whole, the Court found from both documents that the examiner had dissected the claim and compared its parts with the cited documents. The counter affidavit also admitted that the objectives of the cited documents differed from those of the invention.

The Court then took the documents one by one. D21 concerns automated production of a personalised garment using a scanner to build a three dimensional model of the customer’s body, and does not detect the errors or discrepancies addressed by the invention. D22 teaches optically readable codes, whereas the invention uses invisible markers, so its teaching could not be treated as common general knowledge that defeats the invention. D23 relates to end-to-end article management architecture, but the steps in the claimed invention are not the same. The teaching of D24 was not decisive.

The Court held that the examiner’s attempt to refuse the patent on the ground of alleged mosaicing of the cited documents was not well founded. It also held that the teachings of those documents could not serve as a hindsight reconstruction of the claimed invention.

The Technical Difference That Mattered

The Court restated the definition of an inventive step as a technical advance over existing knowledge, or economic significance, or both. It found that the invention uses a new method of tracking the manufacturing process through invisible markers identified by a spectrophotometer, and that none of the cited documents disclosed this even when read together. That, the Court said, is essentially an inventive step over D21 to D24, which the examiner had overlooked.

The Court found the refusal order of 16 April 2025 wholly unsustainable. It allowed the appeal, set aside the order and directed the Controller to grant the patent on Application No. 202147026139.

Conclusion

The decision does not hold that combining prior art teachings is never permissible, and it cites no earlier authority. It holds, on this record, that the mosaicing ground failed because the examiner had dissected the claim and the cited documents pursued different objectives, as the Patent Office itself had admitted. The Court’s close reading of the counter affidavit carried real weight, and it shows that appellate intervention need not end in remand where the record establishes the technical distinction. For applicants in India, the practical lesson is to explain technical distinctions precisely, document by document, during examination, since those submissions may decide a later appeal. The ruling is also fact specific, and rests on these documents and these admissions.

Aysha Sasmin , Intern at S.S. Rana & Co. has assisted in the research of this article.

For more information please contact us at : info@ssrana.com