Invalid Arbitrator Appointment Clause: Supreme Court India

November 18, 2026
Invalid Arbitrator Appointment ClauseInvalid Arbitrator Appointment Clause

By Lucy Rana, Nihit Nagpal & Shuchita Chaubey

Arbitration | Section 11 and Section 12(5) | Supreme Court of India | Delhi High Court | November 2026

In brief

  1. The question: If an arbitration clause names the other side’s Managing Director, or an officer nominated by him, as arbitrator, and that person is now ineligible under Section 12(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, does the whole arbitration agreement fall?
  2. The answer: No. In Offshore Infrastructures Limited v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited, 2025 INSC 1196, decided on 7 October 2025, the Supreme Court of India held that only the appointment mechanism fails. The agreement to arbitrate survives, and the court can appoint an independent arbitrator under Section 11.
  3. Related ruling: In August 2025, a Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi in Intec Capital Ltd. v. Frontline Retail India Pvt. Ltd. held that a unilateral appointment clause does not render the arbitration agreement void, and restored a Section 9 petition for interim relief.
  4. Practical point: Parties holding legacy clauses with in-house or unilateral appointment should invoke arbitration on a neutral footing rather than treat the clause as dead.

For many years, standard commercial contracts in India carried a familiar arbitration clause. Disputes would be resolved by arbitration, but the power to appoint the arbitrator, or to act as arbitrator, was given to the Managing Director, Chairman or an in-house officer of one party. The practice was especially common in public sector undertakings, infrastructure and EPC contracts, and loan and facility agreements. It was defended on grounds of convenience and institutional familiarity. The core commercial choice, however, was always the same: the parties wanted to avoid ordinary civil suits and chose arbitration. The appointment mechanism was simply the route to that forum.

An everyday analogy makes the point. Suppose two parties agree that documents supporting a transaction must be notarised before a particular notary both of them trust, and that notary later loses their licence. No sensible person would conclude that the documents can never be notarised. They would go to another qualified notary. Indian arbitration law now treats legacy appointment clauses in much the same way.

How Section 12(5) changed arbitrator appointments in India

The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015 (Act 3 of 2016, with effect from 23 October 2015) introduced Section 12(5) and the Seventh Schedule. A person whose relationship with the parties, counsel or the dispute falls within the Seventh Schedule, for example a manager, director or employee of a party, is ineligible to act as arbitrator notwithstanding any prior agreement. Under the proviso to Section 12(5), the ineligibility can be waived only by an express agreement in writing after the dispute has arisen.

Two decisions of the Supreme Court of India extended the reach of that rule. In TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377, the Court held that a person who is ineligible to act as arbitrator cannot nominate one either. In Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd., (2020) 20 SCC 760, the Court applied the same logic to appointment models controlled by an interested party. More recently, a Constitution Bench in Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), (2025) 4 SCC 641, addressed unilateral appointment clauses further. The cumulative effect was that many traditional appointment clauses became unworkable. The open question was whether they took the agreement to arbitrate down with them.

Offshore Infrastructures v. BPCL: the facts

Bharat Oman Refineries Limited, which later merged into Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL) with effect from 1 July 2022, awarded Offshore Infrastructures Limited, a Mumbai-based contractor, a contract for works at the Bina Refinery in Madhya Pradesh, including a new Modular Penex Unit, by a letter of acceptance dated 31 December 2016. Clause 8.6 of the General Conditions of Contract named the Managing Director of Bharat Oman Refineries, or an officer nominated by him, as sole arbitrator.

When disputes arose, the contractor invoked arbitration in June 2021 and, recognising that the Managing Director and his nominees were ineligible under Section 12(5), asked for a neutral appointment. No appointment was made, and the contractor applied to the High Court of Madhya Pradesh under Section 11(6) in March 2022. The High Court dismissed the application as time-barred. The employer also argued that, because the named appointing authority had become ineligible, the arbitration clause itself had ceased to operate.

What the Supreme Court decided

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Augustine George Masih, with the judgment authored by Justice Masih, allowed the appeal on both points.

  • Applying Geo Miller and Company Private Limited v. Rajasthan Vidyut Utpadan Nigam Limited on when time begins to run, and giving effect to the Supreme Court’s COVID-19 limitation extension orders in In Re: Cognizance for Extension of Limitation, the Court held that the Section 11(6) application was within time.
  • Survival of the arbitration agreement. The Court held that the agreement to refer disputes to arbitration is the core of the clause, while the method of appointment is ancillary and must yield to the statute. The non-obstante language of Section 12(5) disqualifies the named official, but it does not extinguish the parties’ agreement to arbitrate. Where the agreed method has become unworkable, the power to appoint an independent arbitrator lies with the court under Section 11.

Intec Capital v. Frontline Retail: the Delhi High Court’s parallel approach

Shortly before Offshore, a Division Bench of the High Court of Delhi reached the same destination by a different route. A lender and a borrower had a business loan agreement whose arbitration clause effectively allowed the lender to control appointment. The lender had earlier appointed an arbitrator unilaterally and obtained an award. After the law on unilateral appointments settled, the lender withdrew its execution petition, issued a fresh notice under Section 21 proposing a sole arbitrator from the panel of the Delhi International Arbitration Centre (DIAC), and filed a Section 9 petition for interim relief.

The Commercial Court dismissed the Section 9 petition, holding that the arbitration clause was void from the outset because it contemplated unilateral appointment. The Division Bench disagreed. It held that a unilateral appointment mechanism is unenforceable, but that the parties’ agreement to arbitrate remains valid, and that the dispute does not become non-arbitrable. Because the fresh notice proposed a neutral, institutional route, the arbitration agreement could support the Section 9 petition, which was remitted for decision on merits.

Why the agreement to arbitrate survives: severability in practice

Read together, Offshore and Intec separate the core agreement to arbitrate from the appointment limb of the clause. Courts in India will not allow a person aligned with one party to control the constitution of the tribunal. Equally, they will not treat that defect as a reason to send the parties back to a civil suit they deliberately chose to avoid. The invalid appointment limb is disregarded, and a neutral appointing authority, whether the court under Section 11 or an arbitral institution, fills the gap.

This approach also reinforces fairness. Courts are not rewriting the contract. They are preserving the parties’ choice of forum while ensuring that the tribunal is independent and impartial, which is what Section 12(5) is designed to secure.

Practical guidance for contracting parties in India

  • Legacy clauses naming an in-house arbitrator. Invoke arbitration, propose neutral names or institutional appointment, and if the other side does not cooperate, approach the court under Section 11, relying on Offshore.
  • Awards obtained through unilateral appointment. Such awards are vulnerable. Intec shows that abandoning the award, issuing a fresh Section 21 notice proposing a neutral appointment and proceeding with a new reference under the same clause may be the safer course.
  • Track the date on which the claim to appointment arises and the effect of any applicable extension orders. Limitation was nearly fatal in Offshore.
  • New contracts. Replace in-house or unilateral appointment models with institutional rules (for example, DIAC, MCIA or another established institution) or balanced party-nomination procedures that respect Section 12(5).

Key takeaways

  • An arbitration agreement does not fail because its appointment mechanism falls foul of Section 12(5).
  • The court can appoint an independent arbitrator under Section 11 where the named official is ineligible (Offshore Infrastructures v. BPCL, 2025 INSC 1196).
  • A unilateral appointment clause is unenforceable, but the agreement to arbitrate remains valid and can support Section 9 relief (Intec Capital v. Frontline Retail, Delhi High Court, 2025).
  • Awards made by unilaterally appointed arbitrators are vulnerable; a fresh, neutral reference may be safer.
  • New contracts should use institutional or balanced appointment procedures.

Frequently asked questions

Invalid Arbitrator Appointment Clause

No. In Offshore Infrastructures v. BPCL (2025), the Supreme Court of India held that only the appointment mechanism fails. The agreement to arbitrate survives, and the court can appoint an independent arbitrator under Section 11.

No. Under Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, a manager, director or employee of a party is ineligible, unless the parties expressly waive this in writing after the dispute has arisen.

No. In TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd. (2017), the Supreme Court held that a person ineligible to act as arbitrator cannot nominate one.

Issue a notice under Section 21 proposing a neutral arbitrator or institutional appointment. If the other side does not agree, apply to the High Court or Supreme Court under Section 11 for appointment of an independent arbitrator.

Such awards are open to challenge. In Intec Capital v. Frontline Retail, the award holder chose to abandon its earlier award and start a fresh reference on a neutral footing, and the Delhi High Court accepted that the arbitration agreement remained available.

Yes. The Delhi High Court held in Intec that the agreement to arbitrate remains valid despite the invalid appointment mechanism, so a Section 9 petition is maintainable.

Sources

  1. Offshore Infrastructures Limited v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited, 2025 INSC 1196; 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 982 (decided 7 October 2025; Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih, JJ.).
  2. Intec Capital Ltd. v. Frontline Retail India (P) Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine Del 7719 (Division Bench, High Court of Delhi, August 2025).
  3. TRF Ltd. v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd., (2017) 8 SCC 377.
  4. Perkins Eastman Architects DPC v. HSCC (India) Ltd., (2020) 20 SCC 760.
  5. Central Organisation for Railway Electrification v. ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), (2025) 4 SCC 641.
  6. In Re: Cognizance for Extension of Limitation, Suo Motu Writ Petition (Civil) No. 3 of 2020.
  7. Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, Sections 9, 11, 12(5), 21 and the Seventh Schedule (indiacode.nic.in).

This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official text of the statutes and judgments discussed and seek advice on their specific circumstances.

For more information on Arbitration, Domestic Arbitration, International Commercial Arbitration, Institutional Arbitration, Ad hoc Arbitration, Commercial Arbitration, Insurance Arbitration, Construction and Infrastructure Arbitration, Arbitration Agreement drafting, Appointment of Arbitrator, Emergency Arbitration, Interim Measures under Section 9, Arbitral Award, Enforcement of Arbitral Award, Execution of Arbitral Award, Challenge to Arbitral Award, Setting Aside of Arbitral Award under Section 34, Arbitration Appeal under Section 37, Enforcement of Foreign Awards, Delay in Arbitration, Mediation, Conciliation and Alternative Dispute Resolution, Section 12(5) Ineligibility of Arbitrators, Unilateral Appointment Clauses, Appointment of Arbitrator under Section 11, Invocation of Arbitration under Section 21, and PSU and Infrastructure Contract Arbitration in India

write to us at info@ssrana.com

For more information please contact us at : info@ssrana.com