By Lucy Rana, Nihit Nagpal & Aryan Gupta
Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 | Criminal Law | Supreme Court of India | November 2026
In brief
|
Since 1 July 2024, general criminal liability in India has been defined by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), while food safety continues to be governed by the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. BNS Sections 274 and 275, which correspond to former IPC Sections 272 and 273, punish adulteration of food and the sale of noxious food. The same conduct is punished under Section 59 of the FSS Act as dealing in unsafe food. For regulators, prosecutors and food business operators, including multinational companies operating in India, the real question is not whether Section 89 of the FSS Act overrides the BNS, but how far.
Section 89 of the FSS Act: text, reach and limits
Section 89 gives the FSS Act effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent with it in any other law, although its marginal heading refers only to food-related laws. In Ram Nath v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2024 INSC 138, decided on 21 February 2024, the Supreme Court of India declined to read the section down by reference to its heading. The Court held that the main provision gives the FSS Act overriding effect over any other law in so far as that law applies to aspects of food in the field the FSS Act covers.
Two limits are built into that reasoning. The override operates only on inconsistency, and only within the field the FSS Act occupies. Section 89 displaces general law within that field; it does not erase the general law. This is consistent with Section 1(6) of the BNS, which preserves special and local laws, and with Section 4(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), which applies general procedure subject to any special procedure.
Where the FSS Act prevails: the Ram Nath decision
Ram Nath arose from FIRs registered in Uttar Pradesh alleging adulteration of edible oils, together with the State’s challenge to a ruling of the Allahabad High Court concerning cold drinks. The Supreme Court reasoned that:
- the concept of unsafe food under Section 3(1)(zz) of the FSS Act is wider than the concept of adulterated food;
- Section 59 does not require the intention demanded by IPC Section 272, although knowledge is relevant through Section 48(1);
- the FSS Act has its own machinery for sanction, limitation, summary trial and Special Courts; and
- the Act therefore contains very exhaustive substantive and procedural provisions for dealing with unsafe food.
The Court concluded that, by virtue of Section 89, Section 59 of the FSS Act overrides IPC Sections 272 and 273, so that there cannot be simultaneous prosecution under both statutes. The FIRs were quashed, with liberty to proceed under Section 59.
Because BNS Sections 274 and 275 reproduce the IPC provisions in substance, the reasoning in Ram Nath applies equally under the BNS. The Supreme Court applied Ram Nath again in Sushil Kumar Gupta v. State of West Bengal, rejecting the view of the Calcutta High Court that adding a cognizable charge of cheating allowed the police to investigate the food offences.
In Ravi v. State of Rajasthan, decided on 19 November 2025, the Rajasthan High Court at Jaipur applied both decisions to quash an FIR registered by the police in Dholpur for adulteration and cheating. The Court held that the police, not being a Food Safety Officer, could not investigate food adulteration offences, and left the Food Safety Officer free to proceed under the FSS Act.
Ram Nath also explained the earlier decision in State of Maharashtra v. Sayyed Hassan Sayyed Subhan, (2019) 18 SCC 145, a gutka case from Maharashtra, which had held under Section 26 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 that there is no bar to trial under two enactments. The Court noted that the scheme of the FSS Act had not been considered in that case.
When can food-related conduct still be prosecuted under the BNS?
Ram Nath is expressly confined to IPC Sections 272 and 273. Section 26 of the General Clauses Act, Article 20(2) of the Constitution of India and Section 337 of the BNSS continue to permit prosecution under two enactments for distinct offences, while barring double punishment for the same offence. The working test is whether the BNS charge carries an ingredient that the FSS Act does not address.
- Cheating (BNS Section 318). Dishonest inducement and wrongful loss are not elements of Section 59. Counterfeit-brand products sold to deceive buyers may sustain a cheating charge, but only on properly pleaded facts. In Ravi, the cheating charge fell with the food charges because the FIR did not disclose a dishonest intention.
- Forgery (BNS Sections 336 and 340). Fabricating an FSSAI licence or a laboratory report involves a false document, which the FSS Act does not cover. Merely furnishing false information remains within Section 61 of the FSS Act.
- Deliberate poisoning (BNS Sections 123, 103, 105 and 109). Administering a noxious substance in order to hurt or kill a person targets the victim, not the food trade. By contrast, injury or death caused by unsafe food sold in the course of business is graded under Section 59(ii) to (iv) of the FSS Act, up to imprisonment for life.
- Conduct towards officials (BNS Sections 121, 132 and 221). From 1 October 2026, the Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Act, 2026 omitted Section 62 of the FSS Act, on obstructing a Food Safety Officer, on the Government’s stated basis that the BNS already covers that conduct.
- Non-food articles. Adulteration of drugs falls under BNS Sections 276 and 277. Section 89 of the FSS Act does not reach drugs.
A three-step test: food safety violation or independent crime?
- Step 1. Is it a food safety wrong? Is the article food under Section 3(1)(j), and does the alleged wrong concern safety, quality, labelling or licensing? If so, the FSS Act route governs that wrong exclusively: sampling, the Section 42 process, adjudication under Section 68 or prosecution under Section 59, and limitation under Section 77.
- Step 2. Does the BNS charge add a distinct ingredient? Deception, a false document, intent to harm a person or violence may justify a separate BNS charge, if supported by material.
- Step 3. Is the BNS label only a route to police jurisdiction? If the BNS charge is merely a vehicle for police investigation of a food safety wrong, it is open to challenge. A conspiracy charge under BNS Section 61(2) survives only alongside a surviving BNS offence. Overlapping charges may be challenged before the High Court under Section 528 of the BNSS.
What this means for food businesses in India
For food business operators facing a police FIR alleging adulteration, the first question is whether the allegation is, in substance, a food safety wrong. If it is, the FSS Act procedure, including sampling by a Food Safety Officer, analysis and sanction, is the governing route, and an FIR under BNS Sections 274 and 275 is vulnerable. Where the FIR adds charges such as cheating or forgery, the question becomes whether the facts genuinely disclose those distinct ingredients. Businesses should preserve sampling records, licences and test reports carefully, as these will often determine which statute applies.
Key takeaways
- Section 89 makes the FSS Act the exclusive code for food safety wrongs, but not a general shield against criminal law.
- Under Ram Nath (2024), Section 59 of the FSS Act overrides the provisions now found in BNS Sections 274 and 275; simultaneous prosecution is barred.
- Courts have held that the police cannot investigate food adulteration offences governed by the FSS Act.
- BNS charges survive where they rest on a distinct ingredient such as cheating, forgery, poisoning or violence.
- Section 62 of the FSS Act was omitted from 1 October 2026; obstruction of a Food Safety Officer is now dealt with under the BNS.
Frequently asked questions
Food Adulteration Cases in India
It overrides inconsistent provisions of other laws, including the BNS, but only in so far as they apply to aspects of food covered by the FSS Act. It does not displace BNS offences that involve ingredients the FSS Act does not address.
No. Applying Ram Nath v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2024), Section 59 of the FSS Act overrides the provisions now in BNS Sections 274 and 275, so there cannot be simultaneous prosecution under both.
Courts, relying on Ram Nath and Sushil Kumar Gupta, have held that the police are not empowered to investigate food adulteration offences under the FSS Act. Such cases must proceed through the Food Safety Officer and the FSS Act procedure.
Where the facts disclose dishonest inducement and wrongful loss, for example selling counterfeit-brand products to deceive buyers. The FIR must actually plead those facts; a bare cheating label added to a food safety complaint is open to challenge.
No. Fabricating a licence or laboratory report involves a false document, which is a BNS forgery offence. Furnishing false information is dealt with under Section 61 of the FSS Act.
The High Court, in exercise of its inherent powers under Section 528 of the BNSS (formerly Section 482 of the CrPC).
Sources
- Ram Nath v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2024 INSC 138 (Criminal Appeal No. 472 of 2012, decided 21 February 2024), api.sci.gov.in.
- Sushil Kumar Gupta v. State of West Bengal (Supreme Court, 2024), as cited in Ravi v. State of Rajasthan.
- Ravi v. State of Rajasthan, S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 1945 of 2024, Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench, decided 19 November 2025; LiveLaw report dated 2 December 2025, livelaw.in.
- State of Maharashtra v. Sayyed Hassan Sayyed Subhan, (2019) 18 SCC 145.
- The Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, Sections 3, 42, 48, 59, 61, 68, 77 and 89; the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023; the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (indiacode.nic.in).
- Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Notification S.O. 3274(E) dated 22 June 2026, egazette.gov.in.
This article is intended for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should refer to the official text of the statutes and judgments discussed and seek advice on their specific circumstances.
For more information on Dispute Resolution, Commercial Litigation, Civil Litigation, White-Collar Crime, Economic Offences, FIR Quashing, Anticipatory Bail, Regular Bail, Bail Bonds, Criminal Complaints, Financial and Banking Disputes, Cheque Dishonour, NCLT and Company Law Disputes, Insolvency and Bankruptcy, Consumer Disputes, Insurance Disputes, Motor Accident Claims, Workplace Injury and Employees’ Compensation, Directors’ and Officers’ Liability, Corporate and Commercial Disputes, Food Adulteration Prosecutions, Quashing of FIRs under the Food Safety and Standards Act, Section 89 FSS Act, BNS Sections 274 and 275, and Criminal Defence for Food Businesses in India
write to us at info@ssrana.com
For more information on E-Commerce Compliance, Consumer Protection, the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, Dark Patterns Compliance, Data Protection and Consent, Advertising and Pricing Compliance, Seller Onboarding and Platform Policies, Grievance Redressal, Legal Metrology, Corporate and Commercial Advisory, and Consumer Disputes, Food Safety and Standards Act Compliance, FSSAI Licensing, Food Sampling and Testing, and FSSAI Adjudication in India
write to us at info@ssrana.com